HR10 (2015) Detail

Urging the department of justice to reexamine the conviction of Chad Evans.






A RESOLUTION urging the department of justice to reexamine the conviction of Chad Evans.

SPONSORS: Rep. Abramson, Rock 20; Rep. Patten, Merr 17

COMMITTEE: Judiciary


This resolution urges the New Hampshire attorney general’s office to reexamine the conviction of Chad Evans.




In the Year of Our Lord Two Thousand Fifteen

A RESOLUTION urging the department of justice to reexamine the conviction of Chad Evans.

WHEREAS, when a jury convicted Chad Evans in 2001 of murdering 21-month old Kassidy Bortner, the daughter of Evans’s woman friend, Amanda Bortner, the jury did not know:

I. That Kassidy Bortner may not have been a homicide victim, in that the autopsy of her body measured a heart abnormality that her right ventricular wall was 4 times larger than normal, which indicated some level of heart failure, and that Kassidy’s parathyroid glands were missing, which was a possible indication of DiGeorge’s syndrome; and

II. That there were many photographs available of Kassidy during the period of alleged abuse by Evans, in addition to the one photograph which the jury did see and which led the jury to find Evans not guilty for assault during the time of the October 1, 2000 photo; and

III. That Chad Evans had been recognized in 1997 by the Union Leader and governor Jeanne Shaheen as a HERO of New Hampshire for his role in saving the lives of 3 men from a burning car near Evans’s home in 1996; and

IV. That Amanda Bortner had taken Kassidy Bortner to see an orthopedic surgeon in September, 2000, at Evans’s recommendation, in order to evaluate an apparent toed-in problem, and that this examination was during the period of the alleged abuse by Evans, and that the prosecution’s primary witness, the medical examiner of Maine, knew about this appointment; and

V. That about 9 days before Kassidy Bortner died, Evans asked the owner of the day care center to which Evans had sent his son and stepson, about enrolling Kassidy, and that Evans was told that Kassidy would be eligible after she was toilet trained; and

VI. That no New Hampshire police or department of justice official has ever interviewed or talked with Chad Evans except for a few minutes on the night of his arrest when he asked that his attorney be present during further questioning. The police never asked again; and

VII. That 4 days before Kassidy Bortner died, Evans took her to a family gathering, attended by a school nurse who saw nothing amiss with Kassidy’s appearance. During that day, Amanda Bortner purchased winter clothes for Kassidy with the $300 that Evans had given to her for that purpose; and

VIII. That there had been laboratory reports showing that Kassidy’s blood was found under all 10 of Kassidy’s fingers, even though Evans had given her a bath the night before, as witnessed by the housemate who testified at the trial, and that this blood was inconsistent with the prosecution’s theory of the case; and

IX. That Chad Evans communicated to the police in 2000 that he was willing to take a polygraph exam, but the police did not follow-up. (In 2010 Evans passed a voice stress lie detector exam and in 2012, his polygraph exam was inconclusive. Currently, the prison warden refuses to permit a second polygraph exam, and is likely to be the only prison warden in the country who is currently denying an inmate claiming innocence the opportunity to take a polygraph exam); and

X. That subsequent to the case, a 699-page book was written about the case: EYE CONTACT – The Mysterious Death in 2000 of Kassidy Bortner and the Wrongful Convictions of Chad Evans and Amanda Bortner, and that Volumes 2 and 3 of that book contained Evans’s letters to his advocate for the years 2010 and 2011, respectively. No one from the state of New Hampshire has challenged the facts presented in those 3. volumes. The title came from Evans’s occasional holding of Kassidy’s face in order to obtain eye contact for effective communication, and not to punish or hurt her in any way; and

XI. That the Internet website later dedicated to the case,, would contain far more information about the case than the jury ever saw; now, therefore, be it

Resolved by the House of Representatives:

That the attorney general of New Hampshire reinvestigate the death of Kassidy Bortner, and the investigation and trial of Chad Evans who was convicted in 2001 for her murder. Said reinvestigation would be conducted by an independent pathologist and an independent attorney. The reinvestigation would include in depth interviews with Chad Evans, Amanda Bortner and Jeff Marshall, who was the babysitter for Kassidy for the last 4 hours of her life. The reinvestigation would also include the option for Chad Evans to take a second polygraph examination. The reinvestigation would be completed by October 1, 2015; and

That a copy of this resolution be forwarded to the speaker of the house of representatives and the New Hampshire attorney general’s office.


HR10 at GenCourtMobile

Action Dates

Date Body Type

Bill Text Revisions

HR10 Revision: 28162 Date: March 27, 2015, midnight